About us

Customer service is not a
department, it is a culture.
Matthews Motor Company Used Cars

WELCOME TO MATTHEWS MOTOR COMPANY

A better car buying experience.

Matthews Motor Company is a full service used car dealership. Family owned and operated, we have been blessed to be able to provide quality pre-owned vehicles to the good folks of Tioga County for over 30 years.

We offer state of the art automotive service and collision repair. Matthews Motor Company is one of the area’s only AAA Approved Auto Repair and Body Shop facilities.

 — JASON MATTHEWS, Owner of Matthews Motor Company

CORE VALUES

Our goal is to provide you with the best service and the highest quality products for all of you vehicle related needs in Tioga County. We not only sell quality used vehicles but we also offer service, car rentals and an iCar Gold Rated Body Shop. 

  • Wide selection of popular vehicles
  • Full service finance department
  • Car rentals
  • Body Shop
  • Maintain your car to stay safe on the road
  • We know how to handle a wide range of car services
Rental and Sales Desk

CUSTOMER REVIEWS

Browse just a few of our hundreds of independent Facebook Reviews. 

Vince is by far the best salesman to deal with, he made the buying process smooth and easy for my first time buying a car, I would recommend him and the rest of the Matthews crew to anyone.read more
Bartolo Martin Miceli
Bartolo Martin Miceli
2018-05-01T02:48:38+0000
Worried about trading in my car and financing, Vince eased my mind. Vince did everything to make this experience easy and in my price range. I would highly recommend Matthews Motors! Everyone was friendly and nothing but helpful and getting me into my new car!read more
Emily Elizabeth
Emily Elizabeth
2018-04-19T21:51:13+0000
Great helpful staff, went to get repairs on my a truck i owned from them and ended up getting newer and better truck with the help of Vince. They went out of they're way to drive to me and my to finish up some paper work to Elmira,NY. This is my 3rd vehicle purchase from here and i love it.read more
Matt Price
Matt Price
2018-04-12T16:04:46+0000
Good all around experience-I arrived to look at a car unannounced and arrived with the car i was looking at was out, they let me test drive another of the same vehicle and i enjoyed the ride but wasn't a fan of the miles over 50k, but they pointed me towards the 1 year newer model with only 26k on it and and extra features. The next day i came back with everything that was needed and bought a 2017 subaru legacy, total of approximately 5hrs at the shop with a staff member that helped me setup my own policy for car insurance at a great rate, Vince Coates was extremely helpful and responsive throughout the experience. All in all it was a fantastic first buying experience for not knowing much about what went into it all.read more
Matthew Mmcclain
Matthew Mmcclain
2018-04-09T15:53:49+0000
Huge thanks to Vincent for the wonderful car purchasing experience, I will definantly be a repeat customer in the future!
Darryl Hoffman
Darryl Hoffman
2018-04-06T22:14:59+0000
Thank you Vincent Coates for yet another flawless purchase. You are all top notch at Matthew Motors. Will definitely recommend and buy again in the future� you rock Vinnie!read more
Carla Westlake
Carla Westlake
2018-04-06T16:20:11+0000
I went to Mattews Motors for 2 vehicles I wanted to look at. Steve helped me and let me test drive 4 different vehicles. He was so patient while I tried to decide. He helped me get my first choice - 2017 Nissan Rogue - with an excellent interest rate. Not to mention that he stayed late to help me. I recommend Steve to anyone who goes here!read more
Amanda Paul
Amanda Paul
2018-04-01T13:47:17+0000
Thank you for getting me a awesome car!!! Vince is awesome and could not ask for a better salesman!!
Jessica Williams
Jessica Williams
2018-04-01T00:35:31+0000
Just bought a 2016 Nissan Rogue my salesman was Vince Coates. Very happy with the service. He was honest. He found a vehicle within our budget that fit the needs of my family. Couldn’t have asked for a better salesman as Vince. Definitely will be doing future purchases with him. Thank you for the great service!!read more
Savannah Craft
Savannah Craft
2018-03-28T00:41:43+0000
Excellent job by the service department! Highly recommended! Service was competitively priced, done with in a reasonable time, and was right on point with the quote!read more
Dan Krise
Dan Krise
2018-03-27T20:08:24+0000
Sales department AWESOME!
Laura Jackson
Laura Jackson
2018-03-17T00:31:00+0000
Had a great buying experience with Hannah & Vince!
Meghan Trenholm
Meghan Trenholm
2018-03-16T16:27:47+0000
Just bought a 2012 Ford escape my salesman was Vince Coates. Very happy with the service. He was honest. He found a vehicle within our budget that fit the needs of my family. Happy with the vehicle so far. Thank you for the great service looking forward to doing business with you in the future.read more
Kyle Densmore
Kyle Densmore
2018-03-12T13:53:14+0000
Megan Ashley
Megan Ashley
2018-03-08T15:22:09+0000
When I went to Matthews to have my car aligned the girls at the front desk kept me entertained they were very friendly and giggly
Julie Payne Sherman
Julie Payne Sherman
2018-03-07T18:19:52+0000
Great customer service! Thanks Britney and Hannah for setting me up with my new car!
Devin Hager
Devin Hager
2018-03-06T22:21:22+0000
Mathews has excellent customer service. Tonya quickly assisted me in renting a car when mine needed immediate repair. She was very polite and helped me get a vehicle that matched my style. Thank you again Tonyaread more
Angela Boelman
Angela Boelman
2018-03-06T00:34:50+0000
Super friendly staff. Always helpful and full of knowledge. Tammi is super nice �
Gabrielle Lyles
Gabrielle Lyles
2018-03-05T21:10:48+0000
Stacey McKay is always helpful and they have competitive prices alongside quality work.
Tim Parker
Tim Parker
2018-03-05T16:01:43+0000
Donny N Brenda Plank
Donny N Brenda Plank
2018-03-05T15:13:56+0000
Great service department! Tyler and crew do a great job!
Tim VanDyke
Tim VanDyke
2018-03-05T14:52:11+0000
Stacy McKay is always friendly and helpful. She is community minded as well! Thanks Stacy!!
Tara R. Gordon
Tara R. Gordon
2018-03-04T20:23:17+0000
great people at matthews. my favorite of is stacey mckay!!!! awesome service!!!!! with friendly people!!!
Terri Makley
Terri Makley
2018-03-04T20:03:41+0000

OUR ADVANTAGES

Stop in today, give us a call us at 570-659-5406 or visit our sell your car page.

Service Records. Vehicle History Reports, and a Free Warranty. That’s what you get when you buy a qualifying vehicle from Matthews Motor Company.

CUSTOMER TESTIMONIALS

Thank you guys so much for working so hard to get me a wonderful car!! Vince worked really hard for me and he did his job and what a wonderful person he is thank you very much guys!!! If I ever go for a new car I will be back!!!☺☺☺☺read more
Jessica Williams
Jessica Williams
01:50 17 Mar 18
Great people and honest service with Casey and Scott in the Collision center. Kind, caring, and thorough. They'll never forget you.
Ben Nevin
Ben Nevin
16:44 28 Feb 18
We have bought 3 cars here. There customer service and service department are like no other. Have also used their collision service. Excellent quality work done here
Aneita Shultz
Aneita Shultz
14:00 27 Feb 18
Brittany did a great job, giving us the information we needed to decide on our new car!
Cyn Thompson
Cyn Thompson
21:42 23 Feb 18
Was very nice patient even send someone to pick me up thank you
Bernadette Best
Bernadette Best
11:51 27 Jan 18
On Nov.3, I bought a new car at Matthews Motors. I have been coming back here for over 10 years. I get the best treatment, deals and and respect of any place I have ever been. I have been dealing with John Lamonski and he has been great to me! John goes above and beyond to help me find what I need. He is a wonderful salesman and always is organized and knows his cars! I plan on dealing with John in the future. Go see John.....He will get the job done!read more
Cherry Wilson
Cherry Wilson
05:05 14 Nov 17
Vince is by far the best salesman to deal with, he made the buying process smooth and easy for my first time buying a car, I would recommend him and the rest of the Matthews crew to anyone.
Bartolo Martin Miceli
Bartolo Martin Miceli
2018-05-01T02:48:38+0000
Worried about trading in my car and financing, Vince eased my mind. Vince did everything to make this experience easy and in my price range. I would highly recommend Matthews Motors! Everyone was friendly and nothing but helpful and getting me into my new car!read more
Emily Elizabeth
Emily Elizabeth
2018-04-19T21:51:13+0000
Great helpful staff, went to get repairs on my a truck i owned from them and ended up getting newer and better truck with the help of Vince. They went out of they're way to drive to me and my to finish up some paper work to Elmira,NY. This is my 3rd vehicle purchase from here and i love it.read more
Matt Price
Matt Price
2018-04-12T16:04:46+0000
Good all around experience-I arrived to look at a car unannounced and arrived with the car i was looking at was out, they let me test drive another of the same vehicle and i enjoyed the ride but wasn't a fan of the miles over 50k, but they pointed me towards the 1 year newer model with only 26k on it and and extra features. The next day i came back with everything that was needed and bought a 2017 subaru legacy, total of approximately 5hrs at the shop with a staff member that helped me setup my own policy for car insurance at a great rate, Vince Coates was extremely helpful and responsive throughout the experience. All in all it was a fantastic first buying experience for not knowing much about what went into it all.read more
Matthew Mmcclain
Matthew Mmcclain
2018-04-09T15:53:49+0000
Huge thanks to Vincent for the wonderful car purchasing experience, I will definantly be a repeat customer in the future!
Darryl Hoffman
Darryl Hoffman
2018-04-06T22:14:59+0000
Thank you Vincent Coates for yet another flawless purchase. You are all top notch at Matthew Motors. Will definitely recommend and buy again in the future� you rock Vinnie!
Carla Westlake
Carla Westlake
2018-04-06T16:20:11+0000
I went to Mattews Motors for 2 vehicles I wanted to look at. Steve helped me and let me test drive 4 different vehicles. He was so patient while I tried to decide. He helped me get my first choice - 2017 Nissan Rogue - with an excellent interest rate. Not to mention that he stayed late to help me. I recommend Steve to anyone who goes here!read more
Amanda Paul
Amanda Paul
2018-04-01T13:47:17+0000
Thank you for getting me a awesome car!!! Vince is awesome and could not ask for a better salesman!!
Jessica Williams
Jessica Williams
2018-04-01T00:35:31+0000
Just bought a 2016 Nissan Rogue my salesman was Vince Coates. Very happy with the service. He was honest. He found a vehicle within our budget that fit the needs of my family. Couldn’t have asked for a better salesman as Vince. Definitely will be doing future purchases with him. Thank you for the great service!!read more
Savannah Craft
Savannah Craft
2018-03-28T00:41:43+0000
Excellent job by the service department! Highly recommended! Service was competitively priced, done with in a reasonable time, and was right on point with the quote!
Dan Krise
Dan Krise
2018-03-27T20:08:24+0000
Sales department AWESOME!
Laura Jackson
Laura Jackson
2018-03-17T00:31:00+0000
Had a great buying experience with Hannah & Vince!
Meghan Trenholm
Meghan Trenholm
2018-03-16T16:27:47+0000
Just bought a 2012 Ford escape my salesman was Vince Coates. Very happy with the service. He was honest. He found a vehicle within our budget that fit the needs of my family. Happy with the vehicle so far. Thank you for the great service looking forward to doing business with you in the future.read more
Kyle Densmore
Kyle Densmore
2018-03-12T13:53:14+0000
Megan Ashley
Megan Ashley
2018-03-08T15:22:09+0000
When I went to Matthews to have my car aligned the girls at the front desk kept me entertained they were very friendly and giggly
Julie Payne Sherman
Julie Payne Sherman
2018-03-07T18:19:52+0000
Great customer service! Thanks Britney and Hannah for setting me up with my new car!
Devin Hager
Devin Hager
2018-03-06T22:21:22+0000
Mathews has excellent customer service. Tonya quickly assisted me in renting a car when mine needed immediate repair. She was very polite and helped me get a vehicle that matched my style. Thank you again Tonyaread more
Angela Boelman
Angela Boelman
2018-03-06T00:34:50+0000
Super friendly staff. Always helpful and full of knowledge. Tammi is super nice �
Gabrielle Lyles
Gabrielle Lyles
2018-03-05T21:10:48+0000
Stacey McKay is always helpful and they have competitive prices alongside quality work.
Tim Parker
Tim Parker
2018-03-05T16:01:43+0000
Donny N Brenda Plank
Donny N Brenda Plank
2018-03-05T15:13:56+0000
Great service department! Tyler and crew do a great job!
Tim VanDyke
Tim VanDyke
2018-03-05T14:52:11+0000
Stacy McKay is always friendly and helpful. She is community minded as well! Thanks Stacy!!
Tara R. Gordon
Tara R. Gordon
2018-03-04T20:23:17+0000
great people at matthews. my favorite of is stacey mckay!!!! awesome service!!!!! with friendly people!!!
Terri Makley
Terri Makley
2018-03-04T20:03:41+0000
hello friends u all need to stop on down to Matthews motor and say hi to stacy. Great deals to.
Grant Johnson
Grant Johnson
2018-03-04T15:23:14+0000
Knowing that Stacy McKay works here is enough to recommend it!
Tracey Albert
Tracey Albert
2018-03-04T15:22:31+0000
The rental department is wonderful they make renting a vehicle easy and pleasant i would rent there again with no worries
Bob Mattison
Bob Mattison
2018-03-04T12:42:25+0000
Thanks John and Hannah. Awesome service and very patient. Love the car!!!
Dave Hurd
Dave Hurd
2018-03-04T06:57:57+0000
Service department is the bomb! Dustin was very personable.
Ayla Triano
Ayla Triano
2018-03-04T01:24:58+0000