About us

Customer service is not a
department, it is a culture.

WELCOME TO MATTHEWS MOTOR COMPANY

A better car buying experience.

Matthews Motor Company is a full service used car dealership. Family owned and operated, we have been blessed to be able to provide quality pre-owned vehicles to the good folks of Tioga County for over 30 years.

We offer state of the art automotive service and collision repair. Matthews Motor Company is one of the area’s only AAA Approved Auto Repair and Body Shop facilities.

 — JASON MATTHEWS, Owner of Matthews Motor Company

CORE VALUES

Our goal is to provide you with the best service and the highest quality products for all of you vehicle related needs in Tioga County. We not only sell quality used vehicles but we also offer service, car rentals and an iCar Gold Rated Body Shop. 

  • Wide selection of popular vehicles
  • Full service finance department
  • Car rentals
  • Body Shop
  • Maintain your car to stay safe on the road
  • We know how to handle a wide range of car services
Rental and Sales Desk

CUSTOMER REVIEWS

Browse just a few of our hundreds of independent Facebook Reviews. 

Matthews Motor Company
4.8
powered by Facebook
Elisha Kemp
Elisha Kemp
2019-06-26T00:27:53+0000
The sales department is awesome! My son was on the market for a new car and worked with Vince. He listened to all his needs and wants. He got a great car for an awesome price. We would highly recommend Matthews to anyone and everyone!!
Justin Post
Justin Post
2019-06-14T14:22:31+0000
vince in sales department is phneomal absoutely helps makes sure you know what vehicles are perfect not a single flaw when it comes to his job he was very helpful thanks Vince
Joan Boop
Joan Boop
2019-06-14T01:55:40+0000
my husband and I bought a van in April. we worked with Vince Coates. he was very pleasant and helped my husband every step of the way. thank you Vince Coates for all you did. we love the van.
Emily Seelye
Emily Seelye
2019-06-13T23:55:48+0000
We have bought our past two vehicles from Matthews and both times have had Vinny as our sales man! Always great with service and works hard to get us the deal we want!!!
Jamey Jones
Jamey Jones
2019-06-12T20:28:50+0000
Fast, easy and fair. Quality vehicles. And Vince Coates brought everything together in a calm and patient manner. Highly recommend Vince and Matthews Motor Company. I drove 1 hour 45 minutes to buy my car which should say everything you need to know.
Stacee Harer Bellows
Stacee Harer Bellows
2019-05-08T14:02:18+0000
What was a very stressful initial situation for me was handled with ease by the Service Department. Alicia went above and beyond to create an experience that was convenient to me and the entire department went out of their way to ensure I was taken care of. Highly highly recommend!!
Lauren Gooch
Lauren Gooch
2019-04-05T04:33:07+0000
I love my cute little Kia Soul! It is in great shape and the staff at Matthews Motor Company was so friendly and helpful. They made the process so easy and fun! Would definitely recommend!
Melissa Flickinger
Melissa Flickinger
2019-03-24T15:42:49+0000
I purchased a VW EOS from Matthew's Motor Company for my daughters first car. They were fantastic. We worked with Maia and would recommend her.I live 250 miles from there but I found the car online. I worked, via email and messaging with Maia and it couldn't have been better. She was super responsive, answered any question I had, and even took additional pictures and sent them to me. We were confident enough to make the drive and the car was exactly as she described. It was a great experience, she was super, and we are happy customers. Would do it again!!
Tammy Kohler
Tammy Kohler
2019-03-15T18:49:27+0000
I just wanted to say that my experience with Maia at Matthews was great...I highly recommend her she did everything she could for my daughter and I.Tammy Kohler
Carl Tripp
Carl Tripp
2019-03-14T21:37:42+0000
I just bought a 17 Chevy Trax LT from Vince. He was super friendly and answered all my questions. I will definitely be going back there for my next car!
Wyatt Bedell
Wyatt Bedell
2019-03-04T23:25:37+0000
(Matthews Collision center) I took my Nissan Titan there for some serious repairs after getting in a accident where the other driver took off on me. Thankfully my insurance covered basically everything and the Matthews Collision center Team went above and beyond my expectations! You can really tell that they care about the finished products they send back out there! you definitely have a happy customer here 😁👍
Mackenzie Raye
Mackenzie Raye
2019-02-26T02:40:48+0000
I just bought a 2013 Nissan Altima from here, I LOVE it! This was my very first car payment/auto loan and Josh made my experience much less stressful and nerve racking!
Christina Olson
Christina Olson
2018-12-20T14:05:38+0000
My fiance and I just bought a 2010 Nissan Rogue and Vince helped us out and did a wonderful job. He was extremely helpful and was honest and fair. He worked with our budget and got us a very good deal. I never have had an experience like this in the past with any other dealership. I recommend them for sure. ! 5⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Kiersten Simmons
Kiersten Simmons
2018-11-24T17:15:40+0000
Just purchases my car from Matthews last night! Vince was great to work with, and everyone was so nice! Great customer service! 5🌟 for sure!
Teresa Wood
Teresa Wood
2018-10-18T21:07:14+0000
It started with a phone call on October 17th, after viewing their webpage. I spoke with Maia, and she was very thorough with information and always prompt with her calls back to me. today, October 18th, I purchased my car 🙂 They are all so friendly, informative, and eager to help; I would refer them to family and friends.
Mallory Jean Babcock
Mallory Jean Babcock
2018-10-13T16:12:39+0000
Good service, great customer care and we are so grateful for all they have done for us both in buying a car (thank you Vince) and fixing any problems (thank you Tyler and team).
Phillip Krieger
Phillip Krieger
2018-08-30T22:44:07+0000
We adopted our Daughter Shyanne upon her birth, November 14, 2017. Over time, it was apparent that our ‘13 F-150 STX extended cab just wasn’t big enough for two adults, our 15 year old Nephew Izaic, and our Daughter Shyanne. Her rear facing car seat had to be sat and secured in the middle seat position in the rear, for it would not fit behind the driver’s or passenger’s seat. Not to mention that we were often over legal weight when towing. So began the search for a larger truck to accommodate our family without sacrificing towing capacity, or increasing our current monthly payment. We’ve 4 horses, and three German Shepherd Dogs weighing in at 320 pounds combined, so in our case bigger is better. I had my heart set on a 3/4 ton Dodge or Ford, either with the diesel power plant and preferably the manual transmission. I contacted many dealerships all over Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Virginia that had vehicles that were what I was looking for, and within my budget. I fully disclosed my intentions and my credit standing in the initial contact. So many didn’t even bother to reach out to me. But that was NOT the case with Matthew’s Motor Company in Covington, Pennsylvania. I submitted an inquiry via the CarGuru’s app, and had an email and phone call response from one of their salespeople. Maia was very patient with me, for I was on the fence about the purchase. Knowing that my credit was poor, and having had a simply ludicrous financing offer from an online provider, I was hesitant about even submitting a credit application. Maia took the time to explain to me how Matthew’s entire purchase process worked, and even took my trade info over the phone, since they’re located over three hours away from where I reside. They evaluated my trade and returned a very favorable figure. This was enticement enough that I decided to submit a credit application. Low and behold, I was approved by their lender! Not only was I approved, but I was approved for 100% financing at a high, but not outlandish APR. Maia took the time to get all of my information in order ahead of time, so that upon my appointment for purchase, everything would occur in a timely manor. I arrived at 800am, after a three hour drive. Maia met me promptly at the vehicle I was looking to purchase - an ‘04 F-250 XLT 4x4 Crew Cab, 8’ box, 6 liter Powerstroke, with... the manual transmission. The pictures didn’t do it justice! The body was near flawless. Better than our ‘13 F-150 in all honesty. The interior like new. The chassis was what one would expect from a fourteen year old Ford truck, but nothing a good power washing and some Rustoleum won’t fix! Buying this vehicle “as is”, Maia was certain to explain to me, and ensure that I understood exactly what that meant, right from the get go. She fully disclosed all know issues with the vehicle, which were upper and lower ball joints on the left side, and difficult to operate locking hubs. I test drove the vehicle and confirmed what I had been told. Being mechanically inclined, and having owned a near identical truck years ago, I wasn’t about to let $100 worth of parts and some sweat equity break the deal on this 85,500 mile truck. Hell, our F-150 had 108,000 miles!Overall, my experience at Matthew’s Motor Company was great! Maia took the time to listen to my needs as a customer, and in my opinion, went above and beyond to ensure that the deal was exactly as I wanted it. Granted, we had to adjust a few details, but they weren’t anything to balk at, and such things are to be expected. Paperwork was quick and easy too! Wait time was acceptable, for I wasn’t the only customer there. I was on the road, headed Home in my new to me truck, shortly after Noon. Overall, the deal saves my family a substantial sum of money per month, and we gained more room and towing capacity in the process!The truck made the three hour trip Home effortlessly, and without incident. The AC was ice cold despite the temps in the mid 90’s with high humidity. Everything on the vehicle works as intended and as to be expected. Thank You Maia, and Matthew’s Motor Company for helping my Family ride in comfort and safety, while keeping our budget in mind. Thank You for for putting me as a customer, ahead of profit margins.
Madi Kaizen
Madi Kaizen
2018-08-17T00:56:18+0000
Definitely recommend this place! Vince made the process of buying my car stress free and easy. Best experience I’ve had when it came to purchasing a car.
Jordanne Kontz
Jordanne Kontz
2018-03-10T23:29:09+0000
This company is awesome! Great people to work with when your buying a car! Brittany and Renee were great and helpful through the whole process. Definitely 5 stars!
Next Reviews

OUR ADVANTAGES

Stop in today, give us a call us at 570-659-5406 or visit our sell your car page.

Service Records. Vehicle History Reports, and a Free Warranty. That’s what you get when you buy a qualifying vehicle from Matthews Motor Company.

CUSTOMER TESTIMONIALS

I have bought five vehicles here. This is the only place I will go as the team here bends over backwards every time to make it a positive experience. I always deal with Vince who has helped me out so much in the past several years I have been buying vehicles there. I've had my vehicle serviced at the garage and I felt well taken care of by a professional team. The dealership offers an extended warranty. I do recommend getting this. It can feel expensive at first. However, I purchased the warranty on a vehicle that had a transmission die in it a year or two down the road. The repair did not cost me anything, I had a free rental to use as it took a while for such a large repair (this happened during Christmas week) and I was reimbursed for the tow.read more
Jeff
Jeff
19:00 11 Jul 19
I only visited the rental section of Matthew's however, the ladies inside were extremely nice. They answered all of my questions without hesitation and explained everything to me. I have never rented a car before however, I would highly recommend going here.read more
George Jetson
George Jetson
19:33 24 Jun 19
My truck broke down and had to be towed on a Sunday evening. Opened Monday morning and were great to deal with.
Frank Wasik
Frank Wasik
18:38 13 May 19
Very Great Dealership Had A Wonderful Sales Lady Maia Went Above And Beyond With Ever Detail ..
John Wolfe
John Wolfe
12:30 11 May 19
Bought a really nice truck from here a few weeks ago, and the experience was great. It wasn't a super long process at all, and we're really happy with our purchase. The staff here is AMAZING with helping with whatever you needread more
Caitlin A
Caitlin A
03:54 03 May 19
Wow called them at 8:30, said bring it down and we will try to work it in.Take it to them in less than an hour told me the problem and what was needed some by 4:30. Fantastic service!
Steve Bolt
Steve Bolt
16:48 27 Mar 19
Very friendly, even though they didn't have what I wanted they are going to check out the auctions for me. I will update my review if they are able to locate what I'm looking for.
Rob Neyhard
Rob Neyhard
18:43 23 Mar 19
The repair and services performed were done in an expeditious and professional manner. Communication with the Service Manager throughout was very good.
Redford Bohica
Redford Bohica
19:04 22 Mar 19
Vince is honest and up front. Didn't get a vehicle today, but trust when the right one comes along Vince will let me know!
Roxy Roslund
Roxy Roslund
21:49 18 Mar 19
The staff was very nice & polite. The time we were there was pleasant would recommend them I will go back for my next car
Chris Brought
Chris Brought
19:40 28 Feb 19
Really great place no high pressure and vehicles prices are very good. Sales man super nice and knowledgeable.
Jack Force
Jack Force
21:27 26 Feb 19
Excellent service.fast an curtious Would highly recommend.
Carol hunter hunter
Carol hunter hunter
15:11 06 Jan 19
Nice sales staff and great used car selection
Randy Murray
Randy Murray
17:04 15 Oct 18
Excellent service!! The service part is wonderful. I'd recommend them.
Travis Chapin
Travis Chapin
09:41 08 Oct 18
Nice friendly service and not being pushy on a sales
don kontz
don kontz
18:05 01 Oct 18
We adopted our Daughter Shyanne upon her birth, November 14, 2017. Over time, it was apparent that our ‘13 F-150 STX extended cab just wasn’t big enough for two adults, our 15 year old Nephew Izaic, and our Daughter Shyanne. Her rear facing car seat had to be sat and secured in the middle seat position in the rear, for it would not fit behind the driver’s or passenger’s seat. Not to mention that we were often over legal weight when towing. So began the search for a larger truck to accommodate our family without sacrificing towing capacity, or increasing our current monthly payment. I contacted many dealerships all over Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Virginia that had vehicles that were what I was looking for, and within my budget. I fully disclosed my intentions and my credit standing in the initial contact. So many didn’t even bother to reach out to me. But that was NOT the case with Matthew’s Motor Company in Covington, Pennsylvania. I submitted an inquiry via the CarGuru’s app, and had an email and phone call response from one of their salespeople. Maia was very patient with me, for I was on the fence about the purchase. Knowing that my credit was poor, and having had a simply ludicrous financing offer from an online provider, I was hesitant about even submitting a credit application. Maia took the time to explain to me how Matthew’s entire purchase process worked, and even took my trade info over the phone, since they’re located over three hours away from where I reside. They evaluated my trade and returned a very favorable figure. This was enticement enough that I decided to submit a credit application. Low and behold, I was approved by their lender! Not only was I approved, but I was approved for 100% financing at a high, but not outlandish APR. Maia took the time to get all of my information in order ahead of time, so that upon my appointment for purchase, everything would occur in a timely manor. I arrived at 800am, after a three hour drive. Maia met me promptly at the vehicle I was looking to purchase - an ‘04 F-250 XLT 4x4 Crew Cab, 8’ box, 6 liter Powerstroke, with... the manual transmission. The pictures didn’t do it justice! The body was near flawless. Better than our ‘13 F-150 in all honesty. The interior like new. The chassis was what one would expect from a fourteen year old Ford truck, but nothing a good power washing and some Rustoleum won’t fix! Buying this vehicle “as is”, Maia was certain to explain to me, and ensure that I understood exactly what that meant, right from the get go. She fully disclosed all know issues with the vehicle, which were upper and lower ball joints on the left side, and difficult to operate locking hubs. I test drove the vehicle and confirmed what I had been told. Being mechanically inclined, and having owned a near identical truck years ago, I wasn’t about to let $100 worth of parts and some sweat equity break the deal on this 85,500 mile truck. Hell, our F-150 had 108,000 miles!Overall, my experience at Matthew’s Motor Company was great! Maia took the time to listen to my needs as a customer, and in my opinion, went above and beyond to ensure that the deal was exactly as I wanted it. Granted, we had to adjust a few details, but they weren’t anything to balk at, and such things are to be expected. Paperwork was quick and easy too! Wait time was acceptable, for I wasn’t the only customer there. I was on the road, headed Home in my new to me truck, shortly after Noon. Overall, the deal saves my family a substantial sum of money per month, and we gained more room and towing capacity in the process!The truck made the three hour trip Home effortlessly, and without incident. The AC was ice cold despite the temps in the mid 90’s with high humidity. Everything on the vehicle works as intended and as to be expected. Thank You Maia, and Matthew’s Motor Company for helping my Family ride in comfort and safety, while keeping our budget in mind. Thank You for for putting me as a customer, ahead of profit margins.read more
Phillip Krieger
Phillip Krieger
23:25 30 Aug 18
Very happy with my new truck. This dealer really worked to earn my business. The only problem they did tell the truck only came with one key.
Robert Schake
Robert Schake
11:56 11 Aug 18
I bought my car there a little over a month ago and this past weekend the electrical system started acting weird and what it was as I needed a new battery they gave me a brand new battery at no charge and took care of me very friendly staff great group of people and definitely will be back to buy our cars in the future I recommend this place five stars!read more
Nicholas Cavallaro Jr
Nicholas Cavallaro Jr
23:56 09 Jul 18
Helped me out with a warranty job. Easy to talk to the service department. Will definitely be back!
Rob Wallis
Rob Wallis
13:47 04 Jul 18
Thank you guys so much for working so hard to get me a wonderful car!! Vince worked really hard for me and he did his job and what a wonderful person he is thank you very much guys!!! If I ever go for a new car I will be back!!!☺☺☺☺read more
Jessica Williams
Jessica Williams
01:50 17 Mar 18
Great people and honest service with Casey and Scott in the Collision center. Kind, caring, and thorough. They'll never forget you.
Ben Nevin
Ben Nevin
16:44 28 Feb 18
We have bought 3 cars here. There customer service and service department are like no other. Have also used their collision service. Excellent quality work done here
Aneita Shultz
Aneita Shultz
14:00 27 Feb 18
Brittany did a great job, giving us the information we needed to decide on our new car!
Cyn Thompson
Cyn Thompson
21:42 23 Feb 18
Was very nice patient even send someone to pick me up thank you
Bernadette Best
Bernadette Best
11:51 27 Jan 18
On Nov.3, I bought a new car at Matthews Motors. I have been coming back here for over 10 years. I get the best treatment, deals and and respect of any place I have ever been. I have been dealing with John Lamonski and he has been great to me! John goes above and beyond to help me find what I need. He is a wonderful salesman and always is organized and knows his cars! I plan on dealing with John in the future. Go see John.....He will get the job done!read more
Cherry Wilson
Cherry Wilson
05:05 14 Nov 17